Beard Oil vs Balm + Best Beard Products Reviewed

Beard oil vs balm, which is better? This is probably a question any modern beardsman has encountered. In taking good care of the beard, it only makes sense to use the best grooming accessory that will cater to an individual’s particular needs. In this article, I will dive deeper into the beard oil vs balm debate to help you decide which of the two serves you better. Let’s jump right in!

Beard Oil vs Balm: What is the Difference?

Before you can judge which is better between beard oil vs balm, it is important to know first how they are alike and different. In the following sections, I will describe each of them separately.

Beard Oil

Beard oil is a fundamental grooming kit for any beardsman. Anyone with a beard, regardless of beard type and length can use it. However, it is most helpful in the early stages of beard growth to help with the itchy phase. Not only does beard oil moisturize your skin but it also fights dandruff and flaking.

Beard oil can be applied quickly and effortlessly because of its liquid form. While the shine it provides can be subtle, it will surely create a silky smooth beard, eliminating its rough texture. Hence, beard oil moisturizes your skin, shines your beard, and smoothens its texture all together.


Beard Oil’s Most Common Ingredients

Carrier Oils


Carrier oils are usually produced from a nut or seed. They are very effective in hydrating and nourishing the skin. Since they have a property of not clogging the pores, carrier oils are suitable for any skin type.

As an ingredient of beard oil, carrier oils will help moisturize and assist the itchiness on the skin. Through continuous and regular use, they can make the beard softer and smoother.

Essential Oils

Essential oils are extracted from plants. These are compounds which capture the plant’s aroma and flavor. Hence, they function in beard oils as scent and fragrance. Essential oils are combined with carrier oils before they are ready for use.

Vitamin E Oil

While Vitamin E Oil can be an optional ingredient, when added to beard oil it helps in protecting the lipid layer on the skin from which the beard grows. Hence, it provides a strong foundation for growth and makes hair less prone to breakage.

Beard Balm

Compared to beard oil, beard balm is more viscous. It has a thicker texture and takes longer to absorb. It functions almost in the same way as beard oil in moisturizing, conditioning, and softening the beard. The only extra is that it can also be used for styling and keeping stubborn beards under control.

Beard balm stays longer on the beard compared to oil. Hence, it provides longer lasting moisture, a thumbs up if you have dryer skin. In fact, beard balm can function alone as a skin moisturizer.

Beard Balm’s Most Common Ingredients


Beeswax is the key ingredient of any beard balm whose primary role is for protection of and styling the beard. It can also function in retaining moisture, ensuring that the beard won’t dry out. Beeswax is a popular ingredient in many other cosmetic and hair products.



This is not the usual butter that you find in the kitchen. Butter used in beard balm acts as a deep-conditioning treatment which nourishes the beard. Just like beeswax, it offers a small amount of hold. It has properties shared by beard oils in the sense that the nutrients it contains can be readily absorbed by the beard.

Carrier and Essential Oils

Carrier and essential oils in beard balm function in the same way as how they would in beard oils. Together, they hydrate, nourish, and provide fragrance for the skin and beard.

Beard Oil vs Balm: Pros & Cons

In the beard oil vs balm debate, it is necessary to look at the certain pros and cons for beard oil and beard balm. Here are benefits and disadvantages of using beard oil:

Beard Oil Pros

  • Nourishes, hydrates, and protects the skin and beard
  • Creates a fuller-looking beard
  • Smoothens and softens beard
  • Relieves itching
  • Promotes faster, stronger, and thicker beard growth
  • Has great scent
  • Puts beard under control in a subtle way

Beard Oil Cons

  • May leave the skin oily and greasy
  • Does not provide any hold unlike other styling agents
  • Can evaporate quickly, prompting several uses a day

The following are the pros and cons in using beard balm. Hopefully, we are getting closer in settling the beard oil vs balm debate:

Beard Balm Pros

  • Nourishes, hydrates, and protects the skin and beard
  • Provides a nice, warm feel on the skin and beard on application
  • Styles and put the beard under control effectively
  • Stays on the beard longer
  • Has great scent
  • Adds volume to the beard
  • Longer-lasting moisture

Beard Balm Cons

  • Only second to beard wax in holding the beard
  • Can be too thick to be inappropriate to your preference

Top 3 Best Beard Oil Products

When it comes to beard oil vs balm, the following are the best beard oil products to put in the frontline:

Honest Amish Classic Beard Oil

  • Brand: Honest Amish
  • Scent: Classic
  • Hair Type:  All Beard Types
  • Liquid Volume: 2 Fl Oz.
  • Product Dimensions: 1.38 x 1.38 x 2.95 inches

Description. Produced by one of the most trusted brand for beard care, the Honest Amish Classic Beard Oil softens and conditions beard very effectively. It’s natural and organic oil ingredients is sure to deliver the best beard care every man needs!

“Almost a year later and I’m reviewing this product! I’m still using this beard oil along with a quality beard brush [link below] and I’ve been using it almost every other day! Definitely helped me get rid of my pesty “beard flakes”. Definitely on my list to buy, whenever its empty!” Nick Rinz

The Gentleman’s Premium Beard Oil

  • Brand: The Gentleman’s Beard
  • Scent: Fragrance Free
  • Hair Type:  Dry
  • Liquid Volume: 0.5 Fl Oz.
  • Product Dimensions: 0.75 x 0.5 x 3 inches

Description. The Gentleman’s Premium Beard Oil takes care of your beard in a fragrance-free way. This simply yet powerful beard oil promotes healthy beard growth, manages unruly beard, relieves itching, and fights beardruff as smoothly a gentleman’s way!

“I went off of the reviews before purchasing this product and I am glad I did. My short beard stays soft and manageable. I work in LE and my beard used to feel pretty rough from touch before using this stuff. A few drops last ALL day and even keeps my skin from irritation and breaking out. I no longer have to worry about my face and neck stinging from irritation.” rizzaman12

Viking Revolution Beard Oil

  • Brand: Viking Revolution
  • Scent: Sandalwood
  • Hair Type:  Thin
  • Liquid Volume: 1 Fl Oz.
  • Package Dimensions: 4.21 x 1.5 x 3.2 inches

Description. Tame your stubborn facial hair and have a manageable beard that is soft and smooth with the Viking Revolution Beard Oil. Enjoy its stunning comfort as it soothes your irritated skin while keeping your beard conditioned and freshly scented!

“Great product, smells amazing and beard feels soft after. Have ordered more Viking revolution products and won’t use anything else on my beard from now on!” Amazon Customer

Top 3 Best Beard Balm Products

When it comes to beard oil vs balm, the following are the best beard balm products to put in the frontline:

Old Spice Beard Balm for Men

  • Brand: Old Spice
  • Scent: Classic Old Spice Scent
  • Hair Type: Textured
  • Liquid Volume: 2.22 Fl Oz.
  • Product Dimensions: 2.88 x 2.88 x 1.32 inches

Description. Old spice is a leading brand when it comes to men’s hygiene and its products will definitely prove so. The Old Spice Beard Balm for Men nourishes, styles, and tames the beard like no other brand. It is sure to deliver the care your beard needs!

“This Old Spice beard conditioner has helped to both style my beard and keep it soft. Using this product is an extremely quick and convenient way to take care of my beard. After I hop out of the shower, I just put a little less than a dime-sized amount in my hand and rub it in my beard.” Amazon Customer

Honest Amish Beard Balm

  • Brand: Honest Amish
  • Scent: Clove, Anise, Cedar
  • Hair Type: Coarse
  • Liquid Volume: 2 Fl Oz.
  • Product Dimensions: 1.97 x 1.97 x 1.97 inches

Description. The Honest Amish Beard Balm is carefully crafted in the USA. It tames and softens, fights itching and beardruff, and untangles your beard. It is among the best beard balms you can ever have in the market!

“This beard balm will leave your beard feeling healthy, happy and full. Product smells great and moisturizes beyond belief; your beard will be softer than ever. Watch the video for a quick review.” One&Done

King C. Gillete Soft Beard Balm

  • Brand: King C. Gillette
  • Scent: Bergamot, geranium, and cedarwood
  • Hair Type: All Beard Types
  • Liquid Volume: 3.37 Fl Oz.
  • Product Dimensions: 2.8 x 2.8 x 1.44 inches

Description. This Beard Balm can be used as a leave-in treatment or as a deep-conditioning wash-off beard mask. With its soft and lightweight formula, this beard balm is easy to spread and would leave your beard smelling great all day. Living up to its name, this beard balm is fit for a king!

“I was skeptical at first since I didn’t want something that has a scent but the composition of this one was really appealing; so went for it and its definitely worth it (got it on sale). Have used it only a few times now and I already feel the beard is softer and easier to manage. Would definitely recommend it.” Roy

Beard Oil vs Balm: FAQs

Should I choose only one between beard oil vs balm or can I use them together?

Glad you asked. In reality, it does not have to be a battle between beard oil vs balm. While a beard oil or a beard balm is a stand-alone product, the two can be used together for maximum results. When using both, it is recommended to apply the beard oil first before the beard balm.

How often do I have to use beard oil?

There is no definite number of times that beard oil should be used per day. In fact, beard oil can be used as much as you like and as often as your beard demands.

How often do I have to use beard balm?

Like beard oil, there is not set rule by how often a beard balm should be used. However, there are some rules of thumb for the right frequency. Consider applying it twice a day for dryer skin and once for normal skin.

How do I use a beard oil?

Dry your beard. Depending on your beard length, apply 2-5 drops of beard oil on your palm and spread evenly. Then brush your palms along the beard ensuring that the beard oil is distributed equally.

How do I use a beard balm?

The amount of beard balm to use depends on your beard length. Scoop a pea-sized amount of beard balm using your fingers and spread in your palms. Apply to your beard and on the skin evenly. Style your beard to your preference.

What are the side effects of using beard oil vs balm?

Beard oil and beard balm are generally skin-friendly. However, when allergic reactions occur because of sensitive skin, discontinue use and consult a dermatologist if possible.

Beard Oil vs Balm: Final Verdict

Beard oil vs balm, both have a lot of nourishing and hydrating characteristics. The only difference is that a beard balm has a stronger styling property. On the other hand, beard oil is a basic but essential beard grooming kit for those who want to keep things simple. Finally, the beard oil vs balm debate is about to reach its conclusion.

Considering their special benefits, use beard oil if you want to relieve the itchiness of early beard growth, and use beard balm to tame and style longer facial hairs. Fortunately, beard oil and beard balm has no contradicting properties. So if you’re still undecided in the beard oil vs balm debate, know that there is the option of using both.


Diana used to work as an Assistant Salon Manager in Los Angeles, CA before she started writing for Union of Barbers. With over 10 years of experience, she has tried hundreds of hair care products and has seen, styled, and treated all types of hair. Now, she shares all of the things she has learned in the hair industry and gives advice on everything about hair. When she’s not writing, you can find Diana at the beach on her yoga mat!

Leave a Comment