best shaving cream

The 5 Shaving Creams for Men Reviewed

Although shaving may be down the list of priorities this year, with many sporting “quarantine beards”, as things ramp up again in the US and worldwide – it may be time to get rid of your newest friend. This is our list of the five best shaving creams for men available on the market!

What are the differences between shaving cream and shaving gel?

Creams usually come in an aerosol can, whereas gels come in a squeezy tube. Shaving cream, when mixed with water, creates a foamy lather that can help lift hair for a close shave when gliding the razor over the skin. Gels are translucent which can help the user see what they’re doing when shaving.

During the shave, gels can provide a much more lubricated shave and help the razor glide easier. Shaving creams will take much more rinsing as it will clog up the razor faster, but cream is a lot easier to rinse from the skin post-shave.

In no particular order, here are our best five shaving creams for men!

1. Cremo Shave Cream

Buy on Amazon

This barber-grade cream is available on Amazon at prices ranging from $11.82 – $15.98 for 2 x 6 Oz, with five different fragrances available for your shave. The formula has been concentrated into a tube, with only an “almond-sized” amount needed to create a rich lather when combined with water.

Cremo Barber Grade Cooling Shave Cream, Astonishingly Superior Ultra-Slick Shaving Cream Fights Nicks, Cuts and Razor Burn, 6 Oz (2-Pack)The cream’s ingredients contain no harmful parabens, and consumers can rest assured that this product has not been tested on animals.

High-quality ingredients include:

  • Macadamia Seed
  • Aloe Vera
  • Calendula Extract
  • Lemon Extract
  • Papaya Extract
  • Olive Leaf Extract

And more!

Advantages include the concentrated nature of the formula, with that one bottle of the Cremo Shave Cream lasting up to a year. Top-quality ingredients also make for a rich and fragrant shave – with the company promising that no animal testing has taken place.

Cons of this product include the high price point, with the $16 option leaving many customers unsatisfied that the Cremo product provides value for money over a budget option like Gillette. The cream could be too thick for some people’s liking, which makes it hard to remove from the razor blades and the face post-shave.

I suggest that customers use an almond-sized amount of the cream and combine with hot water with a brush to create a creamy lather.

This product provides a selection of nice fragrances and quality ingredients for your skin without harmful parabens to avoid irritation, but the high price point and post-shave annoyance could leave you feeling irritated regardless.

2. Taylor of Old Bond – Cedarwood

Taylor of Old Bond Cedarwood Shaving Cream, 0.33 Pound$14.99
Buy on Amazon

This cream is also available on Amazon at a price of just under $26 for 1/3lb, with a nice cedarwood scent providing a fresh shave. Again, this is a concentrated formula which requires water to make up a creamy lather.

Ingredients of this cream include Yucca – a natural extract that promotes hair growth and strength, as well as remedying any itchiness or dryness in the beard area. Plantain Extract is also used to provide a source of Vitamin B, and Baobab Oil contains Vitamins A, D, E and F to further strengthen hair.

A big positive when using this product is the superb scent, which is pleasant and long-lasting. The product’s longevity is also a big plus, with the 1/3lb product providing up to 200 shaves. Cons are few and far between, with the high price the major sticking point.

I suggest that customers use a pea-sized amount with hot water and a brush to create a thick, creamy lather.

The Taylor of Old Bond cream provides perhaps the most quality on the market, with natural ingredients both enriching and strengthening hair, as well as giving the beard a fresh, long-lasting scent. The $26 price point is high, but definitely justified. This is probably the best premium-price option on the list, but you might be able to save a few dollars by opting for one of the cheaper alternatives like the Proraso shaving cream below.

3. Proraso Shaving Cream

Proraso Shaving Cream, Refreshing and Toning, 5.2 oz$10.00
Buy on Amazon

The third product in our list of the best five shaving creams for men is the Italian-made Proraso Shaving Cream available on Amazon for $10. This cream has been barber’s choice since 1948, and consumers can trust the Proraso brand which has been providing the best quality products in shaving since 1908.

This cream is made up of high-quality ingredients which are 95% natural, and no parabens or silicones are used in the creation of the product. Eucalyptus oil purifies and tones skin and hair, while menthol oils give hair a fresh minty scent. The natural formula protects the skin during shaving and post-shave, helping the razor glide easily.

Positives of choosing this product include the tried and tested formula which has been immensely popular in Italy since the early 20th Century. Longevity is also a massive plus, with our Proraso tube lasting six months of daily shaves. However, the menthol can be overpowering for the skin – suggesting that this may not be the cream for you if you have sensitive skin.

I suggest that a pea-sized amount should be combined with hot water and whipped into a lather with a brush, ready to be applied to the face.

The Proraso cream is undoubtedly a quality product and has been trusted for decades in Italy and beyond. The formula has been refined to provide the ultimate shaving experience, but the strong eucalyptus and menthol elements will not prove suitable for users who have sensitive skin. At $10 for around six months of daily shaves, this is a very cost-effective quality option and worth giving a try.

4. The Art of Shaving – Sandalwood

The Art of Shaving Sandalwood Shaving Cream for Men - Mens Beard Care, Protects Against Irritation and Razor Burn, Clinically Tested for Sensitive Skin, The Perfect Gift, 5 Ounce$23.72
Buy on Amazon

This premium cream is for sale on Amazon at just under $24 for 5 Fl Oz and has been reviewed over 1,300 times on the marketplace. The Art of Shaving was founded in 1996 and has been crafting quality, natural products ever since. The cream is packaged in a red, attractive tub which really makes it stand out among the crowd.

The information on ingredients is limited, with The Art of Shaving mentioning the inclusion of glycerin – which serves as a remarkable moisturizer, due to the fact it draws moisture from the air and uses it to help hair retain moisture, in turn making the hair much more healthy. The ingredients also include essential oils which both provide a strong, pleasant scent and promote hair growth and health.

The advantages of The Art of Shaving cream are its fresh scent, smooth shave, and natural ingredients – which when combined create a superb shaving experience. However, 1/3 of the tub is empty via design, which we feel is very deceptive marketing. The price is also very high when considering the quality of the ingredients used in comparison to other creams.

I suggest a quarter-sized amount should be combined with a small amount of hot water to create a creamy lather for application to the face.

This cream is a nice product but is ultimately tarred by its high price and limited use of quality ingredients. The deceptive packaging also leaves a sour taste with customers looking for value for money. Ultimately, better products are available within the Cremo, Proraso, and definitely the Taylor of Old Bond brands.

5. C.O. Bigelow Premium Shave Cream

C.O. Bigelow Premium Shave Cream$10.00
Buy on Amazon

The last on our list of the best five shaving creams for men is a product from C.O. Bigelow. This cream is yet another Italian-made product that promises to deliver a “truly exceptional shave”. The cream is on Amazon priced at $10 for 5.2 Oz and has been rated almost 800 times.

The product’s ingredients include camphor, an oil extract from wood which is proven to relieve pain, itching, and irritation – all useful components of shaving cream. Coconut oil provides moisture and hydration to the skin and hair, menthol cools the skin for a nice close shave, and eucalyptus oil to cleanse the skin and provide a pleasant scent.

The advantages of the C.O. Bigelow Premium Shave Cream include its quality Italian-made manufacturing and barber recommended status, as it provides a quality and pleasant shave. It’s value and longevity are huge positives, with the product lasting up to six months of daily shaves. The cruelty-free status of the product is also pleasing. The only drawback is its unsuitability for use with sensitive skin, as the menthol and eucalyptus may cause some irritation.

I suggest that a pea-sized amount be used in combination with hot water and a brush to create a foamy lather. A little goes a long way, so you don’t want to be too generous in applying this. The eucalyptus can give you a minor burning sensation if you do, and  a dime-size amount is going to give you all the lather that you need.

This cream is undoubtedly a premium product with great value for money, but it is hindered by the fact that it is not suitable for users with sensitive skin.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *